Butternut Squash Cake Recipe (naturally sweetened)

WAIT! Before you jump to the recipe for this butternut squash cake be sure to check out the tips for cooking with butternut squash and how you can make this cake even if you don't have a whole squash (it's easier, anyways!)

This homemade cake recipe will surprise you with its sweet flavor and healthy ingredients. This butternut squash cake recipe is chock full of nutritious squash, natural sweeteners, and delicious flavor. You'll be making this lovely cake with naturally sweetened cream cheese frosting on a regular basis for your family!

It is basically a squash spice cake with cream cheese frosting, let's be honest. But a butternut squash dessert is sooo much cooler than an everyday spice cake, amiright.

Naturally Sweetened Butternut Squash cake with Maple Syrup Cream Cheese Frosting. Tastes like a spice cake but has more nutrition!

This Butternut cake recipe and frosting uses maple syrup to sweeten it. Only maple syrup. And, if you are lucky enough to have a local supply (like we are)...you are excited right about now, aren't you! You understand the amazingness that means! Recipes using natural sweeteners are my favorite, for sure!

This collection of our favorite frosting recipes includes all the frostings we routinely use on our cakes! Full recipes included.

Be warned: if you are interested in Pinterest/Instagram perfect cakes and desserts you can move right along from this recipe. This recipe is about crazy tasty, make your belly happy, and feel like home kind of food.

Okay, most of our recipes aren't built for pretty. But this one, especially. But it's so darn good.

Butternut Squash Cake (naturally sweetened)

This cake and the frosting are naturally sweetened, easy to make, and delicious! A recipe you'll make again and again!
4.75 from 32 votes
Prep Time 20 mins
Cook Time 40 mins
Total Time 1 hr
Course Dessert
Cuisine American
Servings 8 large slices
Calories 380 kcal

Equipment

  • Mixer
  • Round Cake Pan

Ingredients
  

  • cup olive oil
  • ¾ cup maple syrup (use local, or real! Do NOT use fake pancake syrup)
  • 3 eggs
  • 2 tablespoons Greek yogurt
  • 1 ¾ cups flour
  • 1 ½ teaspoons baking powder
  • ¾ teaspoon baking soda
  • 1 tablespoon cinnamon
  • ¾ tablespoon nutmeg
  • 1 cup butternut squash cooked and mashed(or can of pumpkin puree)

Cream Cheese frosting

  • 8 oz cream cheese softened
  • 3 tbsp butter softened
  • ½ tsp vanilla
  • 3 tbsp maple syrup or honey
  • pinch salt

Instructions
 

  • Turn the oven to 350 degrees.
  • Beat the oil and syrup together.
  • Add eggs and yogurt,beat well.
    Butternut Squash Cake is an easy and simple recipe that creates a delightfully light, moist, and flavorful cake. An oldie but goodie.
  • Stir the flour, baking soda, and baking powder in. Stir gently.
  • Add spices and squash. Stir just until mixed.
    Butternut Squash cake recipe is easy to make and creates a moist, flavorful, and light cake using only natural sweeteners.
  • Spray (or line with parchment paper) a 9inch pan.
  • Pour the batter into the pan.

Cream Cheese Frosting

    Beat all of the ingredients together and add additional sweetener, as needed.

      Video

      Notes

      top with Cream Cheese frosting!

      Nutrition

      Calories: 380kcalCarbohydrates: 44gProtein: 5gFat: 20gSaturated Fat: 3gCholesterol: 61mgSodium: 132mgPotassium: 262mgFiber: 1gSugar: 18gVitamin A: 1950IUVitamin C: 3.7mgCalcium: 101mgIron: 2mg
      Keyword butternut squash cake
      Made this recipe?Mention miznelliebellie or tag #NBRecipes!

      Hey, if you are still looking for butternut squash desserts and this cake wasn't what you wanted check out these 20 Butternut Squash Desserts from Brit & Co.

      Tastes like a spice cake! This Butternut Squash Cake is full of extra nutrition and delightful fall flavor.
      Do I have to use freshly roasted Butternut Squash?

      No, for sure not. It's fairly easy to roast up a squash and use the leftover butternut squash from other recipes but, I often will take shortcuts to make this quick and easy...

      The easiest way to use butternut squash is to get it pre-cut in bags from your grocery store (found in the produce section). If you don't have access to that and don't want to go through the trouble of preparing a butternut squash, you can use canned pumpkin puree instead.  Just make sure you use pumpkin puree and NOT pumpkin pie puree.  Pumpkin pie puree already has a bunch of spices and sweeteners added to it, so your butternut squash cake will taste wonky.

      Butternut Squash Cake

      Another great trick... the baby food aisle. It sounds strange but you can get already pureed butternut squash in the baby food section. So, if you are looking to save some time, shop the baby section.

      Quick trick for this butternut squash cake: line your pan with parchment paper, spray and flour the parchment paper, and then when the cake is done pick up the paper edges, flip it over (be sure to let it cool a couple of minutes!), and voila!...no dishes!

      Butternut Squash Cake Ingredients

      Maple Syrup Cream Cheese Frosting 

      The frosting for this cake is also naturally-sweetened and utterly divine. You'll be eating it by the spoonful! There have been a few readers that commented and let us know that it works great to sub out honey for the maple syrup, if you prefer. If you do so, decrease the amount of honey by half and then add it back as needed.

      Butternut Squash Cake with Maple Syrup Cream Cheese Frosting

      Cake for YOU. Cake for YOU. And cake for YOU.

      This butternut cake recipe is a great way to introduce veggies to your kids in a new way! Ask them if they can taste the squash in the cake? We bet they will say no!

      This squash cake is delicious. Not, oh my gosh call Mom delicious. (that would be my homemade chocolate cake recipe) But, really, really good. Truly! The kind of cake you could make every single day and not feel one bit bad about. The kind of cake you make for company. Or for Sunday brunch. Or because you had a bad day. It is just that versatile, easy, and delicious.

      63 thoughts on “Butternut Squash Cake Recipe (naturally sweetened)”

      1. Another great trick… the baby food aisle. I know, it sounds strange but you can already pureed butternut squash in the baby food section. So, if you are looking to save some time, shop the baby section

        In above paragraph you forgot a word. : GET between the words can and already. Or between already and pureed

        1. Thank you!!! I've changed that. One of my greatest challenges is grammar. When I got into this business it was for creating and sharing and I completely underestimated the writing part. Thanks for the help!

      2. Bethany @ Athletic Avocado

        This cake looks so good! I love all the wholesome ingredients used here! This means I can have two slices ;)

      3. What does 2/3 c. Mean for olive oil. Do you mean "cup". I just want to be sure since you wrote cup for the other ingredients but just "c" for olive oil and maple syrup. Thank you!

      4. Heather Mason @Nutty Nutrition

        This cake does look delicious. I know you made the disclaimer that it contains natural sugar in the first paragraph, but you went on to call it sugar-free many other times. Cup per cup, maple syrup has more sugar in it than white sugar does. 3/4 cup of maple syrup has 160 grams of sugar in it, 3/4 cup of white sugar has 150 grams of sugar in it. There is very little scientific evidence that maple syrup is healthier than white sugar.

      5. Faith (An Edible Mosaic)

        This sounds incredible! I love the butternut + maple combo and I bet it's lovely in a cake.

      Leave a Comment

      Your email address will not be published.

      Recipe Rating




      Scroll to Top

      PBR Series is here!

      What do you make when your budget is tight, your time is limited, and you just don't have the energy to be creative? We've got you!

      These recipes are budget-saving, easy, and delicious recipes straight from accessible pantry ingredients.

      Join our email community and never miss a new PBR recipe!